Logo
Browse Categories
All

Some links are affiliate links. We earn a tiny commission if you buy (at no cost to you).

beauty-skincare
•Updated 1w ago

Best Aftershave

Best Aftershave - Why Nivea Balm Has Reddit's Heart (And Wallet)

TL;DR: Nivea balm is the budget-sensitive king; artisans (Stirling, Zingari) lead in performance/scents; classic splashes (Clubman) are cheap but alcohol-heavy; Proraso & Thayers are popular highly-rated alternatives

6.2K comments analyzed
r/wicked_edge
1
Nivea Sensitive Aftershave Balm

Nivea Sensitive Aftershave Balm

$7.26Amazon
97

TL;DR: affordable and widely available; excellent for sensitive skin; highly moisturizing; minimal scent fades quickly

611
112
•92 positive•3 neg
2
Stirling Aftershave Balm

Stirling Aftershave Balm

$7.32Amazon
91

TL;DR: great value artisan balm; significantly thicker than Nivea; excellent moisturizer; generally preferred for dry winter skin

220
54
•39 positive•3 neg
3
Clubman Pinaud Aftershave

Clubman Pinaud Aftershave

$13.30Amazon
90

TL;DR: classic barbershop scent; highly inexpensive splash; good face feel, but slightly drying; scent can be too strong/powdery

190
54
•41 positive•6 neg
4
Thayers Witch Hazel Toner

Thayers Witch Hazel Toner

$10.99Amazon
87

TL;DR: alcohol-free and unscented; calming and good astringent; great mixer/layering product; available in different scents/toners

96
30
•27 positive•1 neg
5
Zingari Man Sego Aftershave Balm/Serum

Zingari Man Sego Aftershave Balm/Serum

$20.85Amazon
86

TL;DR: artisanal, lightweight balm/serum; absorbs quickly with no greasy feel; top-tier for skin health and moisturizing; excellent unscented option

100
29
•24 positive•0 neg
6
Proraso White Aftershave Balm/Cream

Proraso White Aftershave Balm/Cream

$16.00Amazon
84

TL;DR: excellent for sensitive skin; soothing and moisturizing; widely available and affordable; lighter consistency than some balms

66
37
•24 positive•3 neg
7
Stirling Aftershave Splash

Stirling Aftershave Splash

$24.99Amazon
84

TL;DR: huge range of scents; strong scent longevity for a splash; many cologne dupes available; great value artisan splash

100
27
•22 positive•0 neg
8
Aqua Velva Aftershave

Aqua Velva Aftershave

$4.98Amazon
83

TL;DR: classic, budget-friendly drugstore splash; refreshing post-shave cooling; Ice Blue is a classic variant; easily found/widely available

76
31
•21 positive•0 neg
9
Proraso Green Aftershave Balm/Splash

Proraso Green Aftershave Balm/Splash

$13.60Amazon
80

TL;DR: mentholated cooling sensation; excellent value splash/balm; refreshing scent dissipates quickly; great affordable classic

74
30
•22 positive•1 neg
10
Brut Aftershave

Brut Aftershave

$10.70Amazon
78

TL;DR: classic, budget-friendly splash; pleasant scent for many; widely available drugstore product; often paired with a balm

39
21
•15 positive•1 neg

More recs

La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5

Best Rosacea Products

Calming balms like Cicaplast & Cicalfate are top picks but can be heavy; Azelaic Acid is key for redness & bumps but often irritates initially; many swear by simple routines with Vanicream or Aveeno Oat; Ivermectin is a game-changer for pustules; daily mineral SPF is essential

6,722 comments
r/Rosacea
See full recs >
CeraVe Skin Renewing Night Cream

Best night cream

Derm-favorites CeraVe, Vanicream & LRP are reliable staples; Tatcha and Farmacy Honey Halo are pricey HGs; focus is on barrier repair & hydration; YMMV as breakouts are a common complaint

7,553 comments
r/beauty
See full recs >
Shiseido Benefiance Wrinkle Smoothing Eye Cream

Best eye creams

often called a scam, many just use face moisturizer ; but dedicated creams offer targeted actives like retinol for lines & caffeine for puffiness; Shiseido & Skinceuticals are pricey holy grails; K-beauty offers value, but Vaseline is the ultimate cheap hack if you don't get milia.

7,591 comments
r/Sephora
See full recs >
Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen SPF 40

Best sunscreens

Asian sunscreens dominate for elegant feel; Euro brands like LRP trusted for max protection; EltaMD is the derm-fave; Supergoop Unseen (or the TJ's dupe) for a primer-like texture

8,663 comments
r/SkincareAddiction
See full recs >
Redken All Soft Shampoo/Conditioner

Best shampoo and conditioner

Oribe & Kerastase often worth the splurge but can be overhyped; Redken All Soft is a reliable favorite for softness; drugstore punches above its weight (L'Oréal Elvive, Dove Bond Repair); Olaplex is polarizing and your hair type is what really matters

7,533 comments
r/beauty
See full recs >
Aquaphor Healing Ointment

Best lip balm

Simple occlusives like Aquaphor, Vaseline, and Lanolin are often holy grails, especially when layered over hydrators; pricier 'cult' balms like Laneige are highly polarizing; Jack Black is a top pick for SPF that doesn't taste bad

6,343 comments
r/Sephora
See full recs >