Logo
Browse Categories
All

Some links are affiliate links. We earn a tiny commission if you buy (at no cost to you).

beauty-skincare
•Updated 2mo ago

Best Lip Liner

Best Lip Liner - Drugstore Outlasts Luxury According to Reddit

TL;DR: Maybelline and Rimmel are the current drugstore GOATs; CT and MAC remain the reliable high-end staples; creamy formulas that actually set are the biggest win; NYX and ColourPop can be hit-or-miss with waxiness or dryness; drugstore often outlasts luxury for staying power; sharpenable pencils > twist-ups for precision

3.9K comments analyzed
r/MakeupAddiction
1
Maybelline Lifter Liner

Maybelline Lifter Liner

$7.98Amazon
93

TL;DR: creamy as a lipstick; stays put; budget-friendly option; excellent color payoff

139
52
•48 positive•1 neg
2
Rimmel Lasting Finish 8HR

Rimmel Lasting Finish 8HR

$5.81Amazon
91

TL;DR: perfect cool toned brown; buttery formula; easy to apply and blend; incredible staying power

186
44
•42 positive•1 neg
3
Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat

Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat

$28.00Amazon
88

TL;DR: overlooked non-pillow talk shades; lasts better than luxury competition; does not budge; smooth application

157
43
•37 positive•3 neg
4
Revlon ColorStay

Revlon ColorStay

$7.47Amazon
86

TL;DR: amazing fraction of the cost; outperforms high end; long lasting through meals; no feathering

110
35
•33 positive•1 neg
5
NYX Slim/General

NYX Slim/General

$5.97Amazon
84

TL;DR: affordable with huge shade range; fantastic texture; matches high-end lipsticks perfectly; inconsistent formula between shades

286
38
•31 positive•4 neg
6
MAC Lip Pencil

MAC Lip Pencil

$25.00Amazon
82

TL;DR: firm but creamy; long wearing for years; does not smudge; perfect consistency

149
31
•23 positive•4 neg
7
Sephora Collection Rouge Gel

Sephora Collection Rouge Gel

$23.34Amazon
81

TL;DR: creamy gel formula; lasts through rehearsals and weddings; affordable variety; gentle on lips

137
24
•20 positive•1 neg
8
NYX Line Loud lip liner

NYX Line Loud lip liner

$7.97Amazon
79

TL;DR: transfer proof; creamy and smooth; stays on after meals; waterproof formula

212
20
•18 positive•1 neg

More recs

La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5

Best Rosacea Products

Calming balms like Cicaplast & Cicalfate are top picks but can be heavy; Azelaic Acid is key for redness & bumps but often irritates initially; many swear by simple routines with Vanicream or Aveeno Oat; Ivermectin is a game-changer for pustules; daily mineral SPF is essential

6,722 comments
r/Rosacea
See full recs >
CeraVe Skin Renewing Night Cream

Best night cream

Derm-favorites CeraVe, Vanicream & LRP are reliable staples; Tatcha and Farmacy Honey Halo are pricey HGs; focus is on barrier repair & hydration; YMMV as breakouts are a common complaint

7,553 comments
r/beauty
See full recs >
Shiseido Benefiance Wrinkle Smoothing Eye Cream

Best eye creams

often called a scam, many just use face moisturizer ; but dedicated creams offer targeted actives like retinol for lines & caffeine for puffiness; Shiseido & Skinceuticals are pricey holy grails; K-beauty offers value, but Vaseline is the ultimate cheap hack if you don't get milia.

7,591 comments
r/Sephora
See full recs >
Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen SPF 40

Best sunscreens

Asian sunscreens dominate for elegant feel; Euro brands like LRP trusted for max protection; EltaMD is the derm-fave; Supergoop Unseen (or the TJ's dupe) for a primer-like texture

8,663 comments
r/SkincareAddiction
See full recs >
Redken All Soft Shampoo/Conditioner

Best shampoo and conditioner

Oribe & Kerastase often worth the splurge but can be overhyped; Redken All Soft is a reliable favorite for softness; drugstore punches above its weight (L'Oréal Elvive, Dove Bond Repair); Olaplex is polarizing and your hair type is what really matters

7,533 comments
r/beauty
See full recs >
Aquaphor Healing Ointment

Best lip balm

Simple occlusives like Aquaphor, Vaseline, and Lanolin are often holy grails, especially when layered over hydrators; pricier 'cult' balms like Laneige are highly polarizing; Jack Black is a top pick for SPF that doesn't taste bad

6,343 comments
r/Sephora
See full recs >